Contact Us | Français
logo titre orateurs
Case Competition
  • The competition is open to full or part time MBA Students.
  • All communications from the organizing committee will be in English.
  • Please be on time as the schedule is inflexible.

 

  • The Competition

All teams shall be composed of three to four participants.

The case will be in English only, however a team may choose to present in English and/or French.

  • Preparation:

 

Each team will have (4) hours to analyze the case and prepare their presentation. They will be assigned a room for the preparation. A computer with no Internet access, a USB key, pens, and paper will be provided to each team

Any participant leaving the room before the end of the allotted time will be disqualified. The participant may leave the room when accompanied by a volunteer.

The organizing committee cannot be held responsible for the technical problems that may arise during the resolution or during presentations. Any setbacks will be deducted from the time allocated to the team for the presentation.

Presentations will be saved in PowerPoint format (.ppt), without distinctive artwork that can be linked to the identity of the students’ university.

 

No personal effects will be tolerated in the preparation rooms. Thus, cell phones, pagers, books, course notes and internet access will be prohibited.

Possession of one or more objects mentioned above in the room in question will lead the team to an automatic disqualification at the discretion of the event coordinator.

 

  • Presentation

Each team will have a strictly enforced maximum of 20 minutes to make its presentation followed by a 5 minute question and answer period with the Judges’ panel. A warning will be lifted by the academic coordinator, 1 minute before the end of time devoted to the presentation. Then another warning will be shown at the end of regulation time, to indicate the end of the presentation.

 

  • Evaluation:

 

The team’s performance will be evaluated according to the Evaluation grid for a total of 100 points.

         5.Judges:

Pierre-Olivier Pineault, Phd - HEC Professeur

Mustapha Ouyed - Goldner Associates - Directeur développement durable

Darius Coté - Imperial Oil

Brice Garnier - Ernst &Young

Sylvain Audette - Gaz metro

Carole Villeneuve - Loto Québec

Panels are constituted at the discretion of the Organizers and will include at least three Judges one of whom will be designated Lead Judge. The Lead Judge will chair the question period, lead the deliberations and cast the decisive vote in the event of a split panel.

 

Evaluation matrix

15  Scientific quality of the presentation
(Quality of analysis. Well used scientific concepts without ambiguity)

15  Quality of oral presentation
(Mastery of the language selected for presentation)

10  Organization of Presentation
(Proper management of voicing between speakers)

10  Quality of the PowerPoint presentation
(Colors, organization, structure)

20  Originality of ideas and solutions offered

20  Relevance of proposed solutions
(Solutions are achievable within the proposed case study)

10  Quality of response and composure during Q&A period

Total
100 points

 

 

sustainable